Madelaine Petsch

(Maya)

Gabriel Basso

(Gregory/Scarecrow)

Ema Horvath

(Shelly/Pinup)

Ella Bruccoleri

(Jasmine)

Richard Brake

(Sheriff Rotter)

Rachel Shenton

(Debbie)

George Young

(Howard)

Pedro Leandro

(Deputy Walters)

Miles Yekinni

(Marcus)

Sara Freedland

(Annie)

Hannah Galway

(Claire)

Janis Ahern

(Carol)

Joel Labelle

(Man)

Kyle Breitkopf

(Teenage Scarecrow)

Krystal Ellsworth

(Dollface)